Prebble, Stuart

Prebble's second novel (after The Insect Farm) is a convoluted tale of a family tragedy, long-kept secrets, and mistaken identity.The plot twists may keep readers intrigued to the end, but the stilted language and shallow characters make the novel less enjoyable.

Jonathan is honest and believable as he tells his tale in a way that slowly builds anticipation and dread. Clues left along the way, however, make the ending feel predictable and contrived. Despite these flaws, readers might find this book to be a welcome diversion from the typical cookie-cutter mystery.