Tell Me Who You Are

Psychiatrist Caroline Strange was named one of Brooklyn’s worst doctors in a provocative clickbait article. Ellen Garcia, the journalist who wrote the article, vanishes, and Caroline is the chief suspect in her disappearance. It turns out that Caroline has a great deal to hide—from the police, her family, and listeners—while she pursues disturbing information surrounding a recent patient and links to her bloody past. Luna (Hideout) keeps listeners guessing through her skillful use of three unreliable narrators. Narrators Megan Tusing, Robb Moreira, and Stephanie Németh-Parker round out these characters superbly, playing to the author’s strengths at ambiguous motives and fractured psyches. Tusing’s Caroline blends self-righteousness and contempt for her clients; listeners can easily understand why a few would volunteer information for the tabloid article. Narrating Ellen’s perspective from captivity, Németh-Parker showcases the horror of slow starvation and psychological torture, a chilling reminder of the life at stake. Finally, Gordon Strong, voiced by Moreira with blue-collar masculinity so brittle it may break, seems incongruous at first, but his importance to Caroline’s story gradually becomes clear, leaving listeners eager for more revelations.