Journalist Mar (Witches of America) offers a compelling exploration of the transformative power of forgiveness, delving into the tragic events surrounding the 1985 murder of 78-year-old Ruth Pelke. One spring afternoon, four teenage girls talked their way into Pelke’s home with the plan to steal from her, but they end up stabbing her to death. Fifteen-year-old Paula Cooper, who was believed to be the ringleader, was arrested, tried, and sentenced to death. However, the story took a turn when Pelke’s grandson Bill, a former death-penalty proponent, publicly forgave Cooper for her heinous act. This act of forgiveness sets a series of events in motion, challenging existing laws and preventing juveniles under the age of 16 from receiving the death penalty. Mar skillfully narrates this emotionally charged and multifaceted story, prompting a critical assessment of the criminal justice system’s role in administering punishment. Mar’s nuanced narration offers insights into the intricate details of the case and sheds light on the flaws within the judicial system. Her vivid portrait of the individuals involved evokes empathy and compassion. VERDICT A compelling and moving book with excellent narration that captivates from beginning to end. For readers of Bryan Stevenson’s Just Mercy.